The Senate continued consideration of the nomination of Priscilla Owen as a judge for the Fifth Circuit U.S. Court of… read more
The Senate continued consideration of the nomination of Priscilla Owen as a judge for the Fifth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals. Following a bipartisan compromise reached among 14 senators the previous evening, the Senate voted 89 to 18 to invoke cloture on the nomination.
Judge Owen was the first of seven nominations which had been filibustered by the Democrats, the minority party. The Republicans who held a 55 vote majority had proposed changing the confirmation process through a ruling from the President of the Senate, upheld by a majority of Senate, that votes on judicial nominees not be subject to a filibuster. This would have changed Senate rules by allowing confirmation by a simple majority vote without having to invoke cloture on debate. This was popularly referred to as the “nuclear option” because of its potential impact on the normal procedure of business in the Senate.
Debate was evenly divided by time blocks allocated to each party. close
*The transcript for this program was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.
People in this video
- Frist, William "Bill" U.S. Senator [R] Tennessee
- Graham, Lindsey U.S. Senator [R] South Carolina
- Kennedy, Edward "Ted" M. U.S. Senator [D] Massachusetts
- Leahy, Patrick J. U.S. Senator [D] Vermont
- Levin, Carl U.S. Senator [D] Michigan
- Reid, Harry U.S. Senator [D] Nevada
- Sessions, Jefferson "Jeff" U.S. Senator [R] Alabama
- Specter, Arlen U.S. Senator [R] Pennsylvania
- Stabenow, Debbie U.S. Senator [D] Michigan
More Videos From
The Senate Republican leadership and members of the Senate Judiciary Committee spoke to reporters following the…
Supreme Court Nominations
Senate leaders spoke to reporters about their consultations with the president on the nomination of a replacement for…
Supreme Court Confirmation Review
Telephone lines were open for viewer comments on the nomination of Judge John Roberts as an associate justice to the…
Judicial Confirmation Process
Senators spoke to reporters outside the White House about President Bush’s remarks on his judicial nominations…