Moot Court on the Rationing of Health Care

A moot court hearing was held testing the constitutionality of rationing health care in a hypothetical case of a non-citizen being denied a… read more

A moot court hearing was held testing the constitutionality of rationing health care in a hypothetical case of a non-citizen being denied a life-saving vaccine. The case of Obasanjo v. Morrison postulated a massive outbreak of the “Simian” influenza in 2020. With the vaccine in short supply, Congress passed a law that gave priority to administer the vaccine to health care workers, pregnant women, and children without making any reference to citizenship. The Arizona state legislature interpreted the law to grant the state authority to impose a citizenship based priority for the vaccine. Isoke Obasanjo was an immigrant who lawfully resided in the U.S. for two years and was recently granted asylum. At two months pregnant she went to a clinic in Tucson to get vaccinated but was turned away because she was not a U.S. citizen. Pepperdine University Dean Kenneth Starr represented Ms. Obasanjo and Georgetown Law Professor Nina Pillard represented the state of Arizona. 

“A Moot Court: Rationing Health Care” was a program of the fourth annual Peter Jennings Project for Journalists and the Constitution held by the National Constitution Center in Philadelphia. It took place on Saturday, February 27, 2010, at 1:00 p.m. in the Ceremonial Courtroom of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.  close

Javascript must be enabled in order to access C-SPAN videos.

*The transcript for this program was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.

People in this video

  • Amar, Akhil Reed Professor Yale University->Law
  • Brewster, Todd Director National Constitution Center->Peter Jennings Project for Journalists and the Constitution
More People

Hosting Organization

Series

More Videos From

National Constitution Center

More information about

Moot Court on the Rationing of Health Care

592 Views
Program ID:
292300-2
Category:
Public Affairs Event
Format:
Moot Court
Location:
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
First Aired:
Apr 3, 2010
Last Aired:
Apr 4, 2010

Airing Details

  • Apr 03, 2010 | 7:05pm EDT | C-SPAN 1
  • Apr 04, 2010 | 4:05am EDT | C-SPAN 1
Purchase a DVD or Download

Moot Court on the Rationing of Health Care

  • DVD
    Length:
    01:49:38
    Price:
    $29.95
    Add to Cart
  • MP3 audio
    Length:
    01:49:38
    Price:
    $0.99
    Add to Cart

Clips from This Video