Bell Ringers
sunshinecavalluzzi Thumbnail
User-Created Content
By sunshinecavalluzzi
On February 9, 2019

Bell Ringer: Time-Place-Manner Restrictions

"You Can Have Both Freedom of Expression and People Can Get Home at Night" - Time-Place-Manner Restrictions

George Washington University Law Professor Jerome Barron discusses time-place-manner limitations on freedom of assembly.

Description

While free speech, assembly, and petition are protected under the First Amendment, the Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed that, in order to promote the general welfare, the government may impose reasonable restrictions on when, where, and how individuals may gather for acts of expression. In Ward v. Rock Against Racism (1989) (a case challenging a New York City requirement that city-provided sound systems and technicians be used for all concerts in Central Park), the Supreme Court established a three-part test for time-place-manner restrictions, requiring that any such regulations are 1) content neutral 2) narrowly tailored to serve a compelling governmental interest and 3) leave open substantial alternative channels to express the speakers' viewpoint.

Bell Ringer Assignment

  • What Washington, D.C.-based example does Professor Barron provide for time-place-manner restrictions?
  • How would the Supreme Court, according to Christopher Wolf, likely approach time-place-manner restrictions on Internet speech? What evidence did he provide to support this position?
  • AP Government- Questions to Consider: How do Wolf's comments reflect the idea of a chilling effect? How could unreasonable time-place-manner restrictions potentially create a chilling effect? How do Barron's comments reflect the balancing act between civil liberties and police powers? How does the Ward v. Rock Against Racism test connect to the strict scrutiny standard used to evaluate some civil rights cases?

Additional Resources

Participants

    Vocabulary

    • 1st Amendment
    • Bill Of Rights
    • Chilling Effect
    • Civil Liberties
    • Compelling Government Interest
    • Constitution
    • Content-neutral
    • Free Assembly
    • Free Petition
    • Free Speech
    • Narrowly Tailored
    • Time-place-manner

    Topics

    AP U.S. Government Key TermsCivil Rights & Civil LibertiesSupreme Court Cases

    Grades

    Middle SchoolHigh School