Can the State Mandate Child Health Care?

The panelists discussed whether or not the state has the right or responsibility to ensure that a child receives standard medical care, even if parents refuse such care. The law appeared to have taken a stricter stance with children than adults when their lives are in danger. Christian Scientists had been accused of practicing child abuse under the protecting of freedom of religion rights. Nathan Talbot of the Church of Christian Science said the real question was whether the government should become an enforcer of orthodox and traditional methods of medical care, rather than allowing the option of spiritual healing. Stefan Presser of the American Civil Liberties Union pointed out that practicing medicine is still considered an art to a certain point, so it could allow for the incorporation of an individuals' personal curative powers. Christian Scientists, though, would usually chose only faith healing methods. The panel was moderated by Jodi Applegate of The Close Up Foundation. close