Bell Ringers

Bell Ringer: Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co. (2023)

Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co. (2023)

Appellate & constitutional law attorney Melissa Sherry discusses the 2023 Supreme Court case Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co.

Description

Appellate & constitutional law attorney Melissa Sherry discusses the 2023 Supreme Court case Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co.

Bell Ringer Assignment

  • On what has the Supreme Court been "cutting back" in recent years? What is "general jurisdiction," and how has it been limited?
  • Summarize the facts of the case, as described in the clip.
  • What was the "question" before the Court? How did the Pennsylvania State Supreme Court previously rule, and why?
  • According to Melissa Sherry, how did the Supreme Court rule? What did the majority decision say?
  • Based on the clip, what message did the Supreme Court give to the Pennsylvania State Supreme Court?
  • What "idea" came out a lot during oral argument, and how did the Court decide?
  • According to Sherry, what is the 'biggie' in Justice Alito's concurring opinion?
  • Summarize the "dissent" in the case. What are the key "takeaways" from the case?

Additional Resources

Participants

    Vocabulary

    • Burnham V. Superior Court (1990)
    • Dissent
    • Dormant Commerce Clause
    • Due Process
    • Federal Employers Liability Act
    • International Shoe Co. V. Washington (1945)
    • Litigate
    • Oral Argument
    • Pennsylvania Fire Ins. Co. V. Gold Issue Mining Co. (1917)
    • Personal Jurisdiction
    • Statute
    • Supreme Court
    • Tag Jurisdiction
    • Veto

    Topics

    Constitutional FoundationJudicial BranchSupreme Court Cases

    Grades

    High SchoolUniversity